Educational Resources

>

Cargo Security: Comparing Trailer Monitoring Solutions

Cargo Security: Comparing Trailer Monitoring Solutions

Who Is This Guide For?

This guide is designed for logistics professionals, fleet managers, independent owner-operators, and shippers who are looking to enhance cargo security and efficiency of their operations. Whether you’re responsible for a large fleet or just a few vehicles, understanding the different trailer monitoring systems available can help you make informed decisions to protect your cargo and optimize your logistics processes.

What You Will Learn

By reading this guide, you’ll gain insights into the various trailer monitoring systems on the market, categorized into reactive, predictive, passive, and self-managing solutions. We’ll cover the unique advantages and challenges of each type, providing examples and highlighting the pros and cons to help you choose the best solution for your specific needs.

The New Categorization: Our Approach to Understanding Trailer Monitoring Solutions

As a thought leader in the logistics industry, we at Level5Fleet undertook a comprehensive analysis of the current trailer monitoring landscape. Our goal was to provide clarity and guidance in a space crowded with diverse solutions. To achieve this, we developed a new categorization framework based on several key considerations:

  1. Preventive vs. Informative: We sought to distinguish systems that actively prevent incidents (e.g., theft, tampering) from those that primarily inform after an event has occurred.
  2. Scalability and Suitability: We examined which solutions are scalable and easily integrated into large operations versus those that are more convenient and cost-effective for small fleets or independent owner-operators.

Through this framework, we aim to help logistics stakeholders set high-level requirements, enabling them to become more targeted in exploring specific categories of solutions. This categorization is not intended to compare specific products from different vendors directly; rather, it serves as a starting point for understanding the broader options available. For each category, we provide a list of vendors to assist you in further exploring potential solutions.

Exploring Cargo Security Options

Reactive Solutions

Overview:
Reactive systems are designed to alert users after an event, such as theft or tampering, has occurred. These systems typically include sensors that trigger alerts when specific conditions are met, such as a trailer door opening unexpectedly.

Pros:

  • Immediate Notification: Provides real-time alerts when an incident occurs, allowing for quick response.
  • Detailed Data Post-Event: Can offer comprehensive data for incident analysis and preventive strategy development.

Cons:

  • Lacks Preventive Capabilities: Alerts are only issued after an event has happened, limiting the ability to prevent incidents.
  • Potential Data Overload: May generate large volumes of data, requiring efficient data management systems.

Questions to Consider:

  • Is your main goal to analyze and understand incidents to improve future security?

Predictive Solutions

Overview:
Predictive systems utilize data analytics and historical data to forecast and prevent potential issues. These systems are particularly useful for identifying high-risk areas, such as regions with a high incidence of cargo theft, and for planning safer routes.

Pros:

  • Risk Management: Helps in identifying and mitigating risks before they become issues.
  • Route Optimization: Can enhance route planning by avoiding high-risk areas, potentially saving time and reducing costs.

Cons:

  • Data Availability: Predictive accuracy depends heavily on data. It’s crucial to verify if prospective vendors have relevant data for your specific operational areas. If not, consider integrating reactive systems initially to collect data over time. However, this approach might not yield enough data quickly unless your operation is very large, potentially delaying the full benefits of predictive capabilities.

Questions to Consider:

  • Do you need to forecast potential risks and take preventive actions?
  • Is your primary goal to incorporate risk mitigation directly in your scheduling?

Passive Products

Overview:
Passive systems include both traditional and standalone electronic security measures that do not integrate with broader logistics software. They require manual actions, such as locking and removal by drivers or yard/dock personnel.

Electronic systems that rely on remote decision making also fall under this category for the same reasons that they require manual intervention. While they may have telemetry capabilities similar to reactive systems, we include them in this category because they actually prevent theft before the fact.

Pros:

  • Low Cost: Generally less expensive than advanced monitoring systems.
  • Simple Implementation: Easy to set up and use without the need for complex technology.

Cons:

  • No Incident Tracking: Lacks automated data collection capabilities for post-incident analysis.
  • Scalability & Convenience: Coordinating keys or managing lock returns is not trivial in larger operations.

Questions to Consider:

  • Is your primary concern to provide basic security at a low cost?
  • Can your operation tolerate the limitations of no real-time monitoring?
  • Is your volume sufficiently low to tolerate coordination overhead?

Self-Managing Solutions

Overview:
Self-managing systems offer a comprehensive solution by integrating the preventive measures of passive devices with the informative capabilities of reactive and predictive systems – coupled with on-vehicle decision making.

These systems are designed not only to prevent incidents before they occur but also to provide real-time alerts and detailed reporting on any attempted breaches or unusual activities.

Delegating decision-making to the asset itself make these systems highly scalable since humans are not required to be in the loop to decide the right thing to do. This provides flexibility and adaptability across different logistical needs.

Pros:

  • Comprehensive Security: Combines prevention, on-asset decision making, real-time monitoring, and detailed reporting, covering all aspects of asset protection.
  • Scalability: Easily integrates into large fleet operations while also offering solutions for smaller fleets without requiring extensive customizations.
  • Versatility: Capable of addressing a wide range of security concerns, including theft, misuse, and operational inefficiencies like misspulls.

Cons:

  • Complex Setup: May involve integration with existing systems to allow assets to download and utilize planning, scheduling or haul contract information.

Questions to Consider:

  • Do you need a solution that can both prevent incidents and provide automated reporting?
  • Do you need to keep your yard processes intact?
  • Does your use case require protecting both the physical asset (trailer) and its cargo?
  • If you are a small operator, does the vendor offer an out-of-the-box software suite and apps to get you started without extensive integration concerns?
  • Do you have additional operational needs beyond theft prevention, such as preventing operational errors like misspulls or ensuring compliance with safety standards?

Examples of Trailer Monitoring Systems

CategorySystemFurther AdvantagesLink
ReactivePhillips Connect’s Smart7™Integrates multiple sensors, offers real-time alertsPhillips Connect
ReactiveSamsara Trailer MonitoringComprehensive data on cargo status and locationSamsara
PredictiveSpireon’s FleetLocateIdentifies high-risk areas, provides route alertsSpireon
PredictiveRoambee’s IoT Tracking SolutionsReal-time monitoring, alerts for route deviationsRoambee
PassiveGladhand LocksLow cost, easy to implementAvailable through various suppliers
PassiveAir Cuff LinksProtects the tractorAvailable through multiple vendors
Self-ManagingLevel5Fleet AdmiralAutonomous operation, enabling assets to take care of own securityLevel5 Fleet

For more detailed information on these systems and solutions, visit the respective manufacturers’ websites.

19231 54 Ave #103 Surrey BC V3S 8P5 Canada

Phone: +1 (778) 400-1922

The Future of Tractor-Trailer Security